Blog

An Open Letter to "JoAnn"

9/5/2017 11:28:06 PM
by Keiko Tanabe - 29 Comments
Topics: Watercolor Blogs

Dear JoAnn,

 

Thank you for taking the time to email me again.  I said "again" although I never received anything from you before but something tells me that you wrote me a year ago as Mr. M. Garrahan, one of your many aliases, I believe.  In your last email as Mr. Garrahan and in this one as JoAnn, your purpose of contacting me was the same: to criticize me harshly as a national-level watercolor exhibition juror for not giving awards to certain artists who you think deserve accolades.  Interestingly, in each email the list of artists who you thought should have won was different except one, Mr. X [name withheld].  Honestly, when I look at paintings to judge, I have no idea which one was painted by Mr. X or whomever.

 

Mr. Garrahan (or you) told me that the artist who was awarded the Best in show in a nationally-prestigious exhibition was a plagiarist therefore should have his award taken away.  You went on to accuse me of not knowing how to pick great art and pressured me to contact the show organizer to correct what you said was a disaster.  I did what I believed was a right thing as a fair, responsible judge and that is most likely not what you want to hear.  This time again, you, as JoAnn, criticized me for the same thing although I was not sure which show you were referring to.  You also called me a horrible artist who has no knowledge of great art and is jealous of Mr. X (but why should I be?):

 

I just read about your horrible paintings on a site called "Bad Watercolor Art". Boy were they right about you.....check it out! Some of the comment were "sloppy looking surfaces" and has "no ability to draw". I saw the same thing in your paintings years ago. I'm glad to see someone agrees with me. I went to your site today and I see that you haven't improved over the years. You are still the same horrible artist you always were. If you ever receive any positive comments about you or your work....they are lying and just want to please you. You're way over-rated and one of the worst watercolor artists in America . Most people who know art realize that!!!!! if you really want to be able to paint correctly, look at the paintings by X [name withheld] and XX [name withheld]. Both have very loose techniques, however, they both show that they have the ability to draw. Speaking of Mr. X, I once saw an art exhibition that you judged, in which he had an exquisite painting. You gave him no award, which told me that you either have no knowledge of art principles or, you have jealousy issues and decided to punish him. Either way, you made a fool of yourself and told me that not only are you a terrible artist but, you also have no ability to pick out great paintings. You really should not be judging in any more shows....it's simply not fair to all the great artists in that exhibition. Not a big fan, JoAnn Wick

 

I have a feeling that you are Mr. X.  I don't understand your obsession with awards.  Art is about you and the quality of work you do which should be a true measure of success.  An award is almost just an icing on the cake if you truly appreciate and respect what you do as an artist.

 

I also think you are an author of Bad Watercolor Art blog even if its author has never identified himself publicly over the years.  Everyone is entitled to their own opinions and I will not waste my time by entertaining yours.  Thank you for telling me to check it out but no thank you.  I feel my time is better spent making another amateurish-looking painting with muddy colors.  I have no doubt that your time as an artist is better spent creating in your studio, not harassing other artists anonymously.

 

Sincerely,

 

Keiko Tanabe

www.ktanabefineart.com

 

P.S. The painting posted above is one of my first attempts in watercolor, "Amore" (2005)

 

- Join me on Facebook and follow my blog on NetworkedBlogs.
- Follow me on Instagram.
- Follow me on Google+.
- Follow me on Twitter.
- FASO Artist Websites - Easy, Professional Art Websites for Artists who Sell

Share


Comments

29 Responses to An Open Letter to "JoAnn"

spesso su fb guardo le sue opere rimango ad osservare , sono bellissimi lavori e' un artista eccezionale mi congratulo con lei ,,,incantevoli lavori ad acquarello,,,,bravissima

How sad Keiko that this attack has happened. I love your art and will treasure your painting. Ignore this person, and know your art brings joy to many.

I am appalled that you have received such a hateful letter. In a way, it is a proof that you are a very well-known artist, internationally recognized, extremely talented, which of course attracts jealousy. It is sad but maybe inevitable because you are an exceptional artist.

I am sad that our internet society makes it possible for mean spirited cowardly people like this to remain anonymous. You are such a generous talented artist and that is what makes you successful . You obviously have something this person wants, such as talent, generosity, grace under pressure, full workshops, exciting painting locations, many requests to act as juror for important shows, keep doing what you're doing!

Love your art work Keiko, your work is all about what is important, big shapes, big values and all the feeling. This sad guy/girl is probably totally missing that and spending hours obsessing over trivial details. I hope to meet you next year in San Diego for you plein air work shop. Btw, The bad water color site is a pretty sad reflection of our times. Just remember, don't feed the trolls!!! keep on keeping on.

Obviously after reading the so called "Mr Bad Artist Blog" on demoralizing your work that HE has no clue of the great impact and appreciation by world wide artists whether by fellow watercolorists or other media that appreciate your work. I guess he hasn't learned anything from the way you approach and enhance the subject matter your are painting whether in person or from your reference photos in your studio. As a fellow longtime watercolorist, I have learned new and interesting tips from viewing your paintings from color , composition design and style. He's just jealous of your wide world recognition of a very talented artist!! Keep up the wonderful painting and ignore the obnoxious "Mr Bad Artist Blog"!
Karen

I too am absolutely stunned by this hate-filled letter. Your art is wonderful and you are very talented. In this day of the anonymous internet, we will see and hear more and more from these troglodytes and that is so sad. Someday I hope to be as successful an artist as you are now!

Keiko I adore your exquisite art ! Truly a gift from God. There will always be people out there crit sizing and putting others down because it's their own bad wellsprings, and I admire your mature response to such an attack. Shows you know who you are and your abilities and are not moved by the comments or egos of others. Well done and keep doing your beautiful amazing work !!

I have a pile of completed questionaires from students who participated in your 5-day workshop here in Kenosha in 2016...... It's not just my opinion, but shared by all. You are an excellent instructor and a wonderful artist. I am honored to have gotten to know you.

In my personal opinion, as well as many others who I have spoken to over the last few years, is that your work is amazing. I treasure some of the drawing advice you gave during the workshop I took with you. I personally am sick and tired of people who have nothing better to do with their time then be mean spirited, I am sure the live a sad and lonely life. Your art gives the world more beauty for us all to enjoy.

Jealousy is a terrible thing. It eats from the inside however it makes a strong statement. It says -Here is something to envy, to want, to be. Keiko your art is wonderful ignore this. It is someone else's problem. I loved everything about your workshops, your generous advice and watching you create your beautiful work.

Thank you so much, everyone, for visiting my blog and responding to what I had to say. In writing this open letter, my intent was to let "JoAnn" know that this kind of harassment is simply not acceptable and does a great disservice to all, including herself, in the art community. If it continues, I'm not afraid of going public with more information that I have about this person. Grazie, Massimo, per il tuo bel commento.

What is most beautiful about this is your capacity to respond with love and wisdom and peace in the face of such rancor and self-loathing.

Keiko,
I have experienced the vengeance of hateful family members. It was severe enough that I went to a counselor to try to get over it. Here is what I've come to believe: what a person says is about them; what I say is about me.

The way I have healed from vicious words is to make or find a list of affirmations. Think about them, say them out loud. Write them down, paint them, express them until they become more true in your heart that what the bully said.

Your gentleness and sweetness comes through in your paintings. You are beautiful in your heart. Unfortunately, people with resentments and fury look for the gentle ones among us to download their shame onto. They think we are too weak to fight it off. So in "winning" over us they feel they have "won" over their shame. But it doesn't work for so they go on looking for new targets.

What works for me is to make a new plan and get excited about something in the future and work toward. That is really the only way I change the feeling. We are visual people. Artists are visual. We visualize our feelings. We have to change the channel and visualize something that makes us happy.

Thank you, Jim, great to hear from you. Thank you, too, Jann, for your valuable comment. My point is only this: It's obvious that this person desperately wants an award in a prestigious exhibition so he threats a juror in a most cowardly way as exhibited in his letter to me. One can only imagine how many jurors have been targets of his nonsense, and it has to stop.

Keiko, I personally think that's jealousy only.
Regards by streetdrawingsmauser.net

Keiko,

I have admired your paintings and skillful use of shapes and values to suggest rather than delineate completely. I also admired your calm and spirited response - it made me think even more of you. Thank you for the beautiful work that you do!

Dear Keiko, I'm absolutely shocked that anyone would write such mean-spirited rubbish to you! It is obviously a case of self-loathing, and serious jealousy. They will be eaten from the inside out by it. I have loved your work ever since I came across it many years ago....(perhaps 2007 on the Daily Painters site). I've enjoyed some of your videos and books - love watching you paint! (and proud of the painting of yours that I own!) Keep up the beautiful inspiring work my dear painter friend! Cheers and blessings to you, Roxanne.

Mauser, Mary, Roxanne, I so appreciate the time you took to read my blog and comment here. This letter may be an example that the art community is not immune to negativity but we can choose not to participate. Happy painting!

Dear Keiko,

I am appalled at this hateful letter. We all know in our minds that an individual of this caliber is a sad, pitiful, human who lacks self-esteem, but it still hurts the heart. Please rest assured that your talent is beyond compare and brings a smile to the souls of many every time we have the pleasure of seeing one of your pieces!

I suppose the price of "daring greatly" is that we are suddenly thrust into the arena where, even those who have not learned how to be content within themselves, are able to tear down the ones who are!

March forward beautiful artist! :)

Hello Pam, thank you for such a heart-warming comment! Being an artist is a journey, and like any other journey, it's a rocky road where you meet all kinds of people. I wish it was always sweet as chocolate but c'est la vie.

You are one of the most talented and generous artists and nothing will take that away !

What Pam said was 200 percent right, as well as every other positive comment.

Funny how a beautiful vase filled with water is clouded by one drop of ink. Bad ink no, it isn't a bit funny.

(My website is under construction)

He/She is envious of your talent and place in the art world. A bitter old person full of hate. Must be quite insecure and lashing at people . Loved you response to her letter. I love your generosity in sharing your talent. Continue the good work.

An open response to Mr. X and/or Joann Wick;
I am an artist, still learning, but thrilled to have received 3 awards so far. I keep a list in my computer of artists whose work I admire so that I can study their work. I do not remember all their names, but Keiko Tanabe is one artist whose name I do remember because of her fine work in watercolor - a medium I am now venturing into under my classically trained teacher. I revisit her website frequently and always learn something to apply in my own painting. I pray that you will repent and ask God to take away the bitter envy and hatefulness in your heart and give you His peace.

I got a hateful message like this recently. It says so much about the sender; if you're a capable artist, and confident in your style, there's no reason to lash out at anyone, or even make comparisons. You just sit and down and paint; what other people are doing isn't a factor.

After having listened to your recent interview for the Plein Air Magazine podcast I decided to explore your website.

You have done a great service to the art community by posting an open letter critical of your work as an artist and as an art juror.

Art classes would benefit from discussing the letter, your (and others') responses, and the merits and impact of such vitriol expressed by X. The letter could trigger fruitful discussion topics, such as: What makes for great/poor art? What qualities should a juror seek in an art contest? Do art contests and art jurors measure artistic abilities? Where do you draw the line in art criticism through social media? (and many more)

Again, thank you for this reality check as I tackle my own artistic journey.

Dear Keiko, I'm sorry you received such an awful email. You are one of my favourite artists to learn from, I admire you very much, and I enjoy your videos and blog. Thank you for being so generous with your art and your knowledge.

Thank you everyone for sending your thoughtful, insightful feedback as a response to this blog post that I wrote a while back. To update, "JoAnn" has never responded to me, publicly or privately, which probably means none of what I or you said was read by her. However, I am grateful that her letter provided an opportunity to open quite an interesting discussion as we see in the comment thread. A lesson learned, for me, was that differences in our opinion as artists should never be used as an excuse for a personal attack. If we all learn to embrace and respect our differences, we all grow and our community will be stronger because of that.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post