Blog
An Open Letter to "JoAnn"
9/5/2017 11:28:06 PM
by Keiko Tanabe - 29 Comments
Topics: Watercolor Blogs
Dear JoAnn,
Thank you for taking the time to email me again. I said "again" although I never received anything from you before but something tells me that you wrote me a year ago as Mr. M. Garrahan, one of your many aliases, I believe. In your last email as Mr. Garrahan and in this one as JoAnn, your purpose of contacting me was the same: to criticize me harshly as a national-level watercolor exhibition juror for not giving awards to certain artists who you think deserve accolades. Interestingly, in each email the list of artists who you thought should have won was different except one, Mr. X [name withheld]. Honestly, when I look at paintings to judge, I have no idea which one was painted by Mr. X or whomever.
Mr. Garrahan (or you) told me that the artist who was awarded the Best in show in a nationally-prestigious exhibition was a plagiarist therefore should have his award taken away. You went on to accuse me of not knowing how to pick great art and pressured me to contact the show organizer to correct what you said was a disaster. I did what I believed was a right thing as a fair, responsible judge and that is most likely not what you want to hear. This time again, you, as JoAnn, criticized me for the same thing although I was not sure which show you were referring to. You also called me a horrible artist who has no knowledge of great art and is jealous of Mr. X (but why should I be?):
I just read about your horrible paintings on a site called "Bad Watercolor Art". Boy were they right about you.....check it out! Some of the comment were "sloppy looking surfaces" and has "no ability to draw". I saw the same thing in your paintings years ago. I'm glad to see someone agrees with me. I went to your site today and I see that you haven't improved over the years. You are still the same horrible artist you always were. If you ever receive any positive comments about you or your work....they are lying and just want to please you. You're way over-rated and one of the worst watercolor artists in America . Most people who know art realize that!!!!! if you really want to be able to paint correctly, look at the paintings by X [name withheld] and XX [name withheld]. Both have very loose techniques, however, they both show that they have the ability to draw. Speaking of Mr. X, I once saw an art exhibition that you judged, in which he had an exquisite painting. You gave him no award, which told me that you either have no knowledge of art principles or, you have jealousy issues and decided to punish him. Either way, you made a fool of yourself and told me that not only are you a terrible artist but, you also have no ability to pick out great paintings. You really should not be judging in any more shows....it's simply not fair to all the great artists in that exhibition. Not a big fan, JoAnn Wick
I have a feeling that you are Mr. X. I don't understand your obsession with awards. Art is about you and the quality of work you do which should be a true measure of success. An award is almost just an icing on the cake if you truly appreciate and respect what you do as an artist.
I also think you are an author of Bad Watercolor Art blog even if its author has never identified himself publicly over the years. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions and I will not waste my time by entertaining yours. Thank you for telling me to check it out but no thank you. I feel my time is better spent making another amateurish-looking painting with muddy colors. I have no doubt that your time as an artist is better spent creating in your studio, not harassing other artists anonymously.
Sincerely,
Keiko Tanabe
www.ktanabefineart.com
P.S. The painting posted above is one of my first attempts in watercolor, "Amore" (2005)
- Join me on Facebook and follow my blog on NetworkedBlogs.
- Follow me on Instagram.
- Follow me on Google+.
- Follow me on Twitter.
- FASO Artist Websites - Easy, Professional Art Websites for Artists who Sell

